When we launched our first Tucson short-term rental in 2021, we wanted two things: to show up wherever guests look, and a way to keep a guest once we'd earned the right to. We were on Airbnb and Vrbo from day one, with our own booking site up within two months. We launched our second house two years later.
It's been a good business: solid net income, handy tax benefits, and the fun of running a small, hands-on hospitality operation.
From the beginning, I kinda knew where Airbnb was headed. I'd had a front-row seat at Amazon, where the flywheel moved friction and cost from the customer to the seller. Some sellers don't make it. The flywheel doesn't need them to.
Over five years, I've watched Airbnb run the same playbook, and none of it has surprised me. It's been a slow boil for the host frog: a small change here, another there.
The latest move: it's is a big one.
Some context:
Hosts have always set their own house rules: checkout chores, fines, rental agreements, ID checks. Those rules are how an owner protects a home a stranger is sleeping in. On October 20, Airbnb emailed hosts that it was "simplifying" them.
Every change points the same direction. Guests get a more consistent stay. The guest becomes Airbnb's customer, not the host's. And hosts keep losing say over how they run their own business.
Here are the big ones:
No separate contracts. Rental agreements are out for most nightly stays, even though some property managers say their insurance depends on one.
Stripped-down rules. Hosts pick from seven standard rules. Anything else has to be "reasonable." No asking guests to strip beds, wash dishes, or haul trash. Airbnb's new rules editor flagged two of mine: "take trash to bins next to house" and "load and start dishwasher."
No guest data. Check an ID, don't keep a copy. No third-party check-in apps. No Wi-Fi portals that grab an email.
Hosts pushed back: a 20,000-signature petition, and a booking blackout planned for November 20. Most aren't defending ten-step checkout lists. They're losing tools that protect their homes, and they don't trust Airbnb to fill the gap. It'll be interesting to see if Airbnb budges.
Guests cheered, and they have a point. Pay a cleaning fee, then get a ten-step checkout list? That's a bad deal. Airbnb is listening to its customers, and some consistency is overdue.
But a home will never be a hotel. Taking out the trash or starting the dishwasher isn't an onerous chore. So the question isn't whether Airbnb should set limits. It's whether this version, which pushes hosts to run a home like a hotel, dismantles the equilibrium that got homeowners to let strangers stay in their homes in the first place.
To be clear, I'm not complaining. We've already changed our rules. Both our homes are upscale, and out of more than 200 guests, we've had two bad ones, and even those were more head-scratchers vs monetary loss. Most do more than we ask before they leave. If our cleaners have to start the dishwasher and take out the trash, it won't touch our economics.
My questions here are about the ecosystem, not our two houses.
Amazon sellers in the 2000s got a great deal: cheap access to a firehose of buyers. Then the deal changed. By most counts, Amazon's cut of each sale, fees and ads included, went from about a third in 2016 to over half by 2022. Returns on seller-shipped orders went automatic in 2017, label on the seller's tab.
As we all know, the Amazon marketplace did fine. Amazon never needed any one seller to stay.
Now Airbnb. This fall it moved hosts to a single 15.5% fee and dropped the guest fee. The cut didn't grow. The whole bill moved to the host's side of the table. Then it took away chores, fines, and most contracts. The same week, Brian Chesky told investors Airbnb is "back in growth mode."
As a guest, I'd take that deal. That's the flywheel working. Airbnb isn't the villain here, any more than Amazon was.
One asterisk: the deal only holds as long as hosts stay hosts.
And that's the risk. Amazon's playbook may not "travel" [see what I did there?]. A shoe brand that leaves Amazon still has to sell shoes somewhere. A host who leaves Airbnb can stop being a host.
Most hosts aren't enterprise sellers, for whom a platform is an existential necessity. In Airbnb's own Oregon data, 92% of hosts had two or fewer listings in 2023. They own an extra home, and they can do almost anything with it. Sell it. Rent it long-term. Or skip the platforms and keep it as a vacation home with a few direct bookings thrown in.
Those exits don't leave for a competitor, leave the category.
And direct booking is not the answer some hosts wish it were. Even for hotels, that isn't the answer. From what I've read, Hilton spent something like $100 million telling travelers to stop clicking around, and hotels still get roughly half their bookings through OTAs. At our first Tucson house, direct brings in 40% of revenue, not enough to survive on.
This could be an opening for Vrbo. A platform that told hosts "your house, your rules" would have a ready audience of 20,000 petition signers. Instead, Vrbo raised its host commission to 12% in October, and in my experience it has always been less flexible with hosts. I don't see it happening, but I'd love to see Vrbo counterposition here.
I'm not predicting an exodus of hosts. The risk is momentum. A flywheel that's spinning up is hard to stop. One that's slowing down is hard to restart, and this is the risk Airbnb is taking.
A shoe brand without a retailer is a warehouse full of shoes. A host without Airbnb is still a homeowner with a, um host of options.
I don't think Airbnb made these changes because it wanted to. Cities from New York to Barcelona are squeezing its supply of homes, and Wall Street wants growth. So this spring Airbnb added boutique hotels and car rentals, and Chesky started talking about becoming an "Amazon for services."
Amazon didn't invent retail. It got the best at it. Airbnb did create short-term rentals at scale, by building a marketplace that, so far, has kept hosts and guests in balance. Eighteen years in, it's chasing growth by asking more of the hosts who built it, and by adding the hotels it was built to beat.
Boiling the frog, or jumping the shark? Ask me again in a year.
PS: Speaking of direct bookings: if you want great hiking, biking, and winter warmth in a fun city, check out www.tucsonparadise.com. Use code LINKEDIN for 20% off when you book direct ;)